Case Review

Case Review

A credible innocence claim deserves disciplined review. ROAR Kingdom begins with evidence suggesting the convicted person may not have committed the crime.

How ROAR reviews a case

  1. Case Identity. Court, jurisdiction, case number, offense, sentence, custody status, attorney status, and urgent deadlines.
  2. Procedural History. Arrest, trial, sentencing, appeal, post-conviction proceedings, habeas, parole, prior innocence claims, and current procedural posture.
  3. State’s Theory. What prosecutors said happened and what evidence they relied upon.
  4. Defense Theory. What was presented and what potentially available defense was not presented.
  5. Innocence Evidence. DNA, forensic, digital, location, video, alibi, alternate-suspect, recantation, impeachment, medical, timeline, or exclusion evidence.
  6. Contradictions. Police reports versus testimony, earlier versus later statements, prosecution argument versus record, forensic claims versus laboratory files, and appellate descriptions versus trial evidence.
  7. Missing Evidence. Discovery, transcripts, exhibits, lab files, police files, interviews, video, phone records, prior statements, or potential Brady/Giglio material.
  8. Reinvestigation Plan. What should now be located, tested, disclosed, compared, reconstructed, or professionally reviewed.

What strengthens a case

  • Affirmative evidence pointing away from the defendant
  • Forensic exclusion or testable physical evidence
  • Credible new witnesses, recantations, or alternate-suspect evidence
  • Provably false or impossible testimony
  • Suppressed or newly discovered exculpatory evidence
  • Major contradictions in the record
  • Digital or location evidence capable of testing the State’s timeline

Before submitting

Please do not send original or irreplaceable evidence. Start with copies and a clear explanation of why the person may be factually innocent. Identify any known legal deadlines immediately. If an attorney currently represents the person, say so.

ROAR Kingdom is not a law firm. Case review, organization, investigation support, referral, public education, and advocacy do not create an attorney-client relationship. A licensed attorney should advise on legal strategy, filings, deadlines, preservation, exhaustion, and jurisdiction-specific requirements.